Bracket Championships
Bilbo Baggins
Bilbo is a comfort-loving hobbit who slowly becomes brave, clever, and morally strong. His choices drive much of The Hobbit because he saves the dwarves many times, faces danger even when afraid, and finally tries to prevent war by giving Bard the Arkenstone.
Romeo
Romeo is emotional, romantic, and impulsive. His love for Juliet drives the plot of Romeo and Juliet, but his quick decisions, especially killing Tybalt and rushing into death, help turn the love story into a tragedy.
Juliet
Juliet begins as obedient and sheltered, but she becomes brave, independent, and determined. Her choices move the plot forward because she risks her family’s anger, secretly marries Romeo, and tries to control her own future in a world ruled by family conflict.
Frederick Douglass
Douglass is the narrator and central figure of his Narrative. His journey from enslavement toward freedom shapes the whole text. His desire to read, think, resist, and claim his own identity makes him a powerful example of courage, intelligence, and self-determination.
Thorin Oakenshield
Thorin is the proud leader of the dwarves and heir to the Lonely Mountain. His courage helps reclaim the Mountain, but his greed and pride nearly cause war. His final apology to Bilbo helps complete the book’s theme that character matters more than treasure.
Lord Capulet
Lord Capulet is Juliet’s father and a powerful figure in her life. At first he seems protective, but later he becomes controlling and angry when Juliet refuses to marry Paris. His pressure helps push Juliet toward desperate choices.
Gandalf
Gandalf is the wise guide who sets Bilbo’s adventure in motion. He helps the characters when danger becomes too great, but he also lets Bilbo grow by facing challenges himself. His contribution is guidance, wisdom, and perfectly timed intervention.
The Nurse
The Nurse is Juliet’s caretaker, messenger, and emotional support. She helps Romeo and Juliet communicate and secretly marry, but later advises Juliet to forget Romeo and marry Paris. Her shifting support leaves Juliet feeling more alone.
Bard
Bard is the calm, practical archer from Lake-town who kills Smaug. After the dragon’s death, he becomes a leader who speaks for his suffering people. His role in the plot is to bring justice, reason, and responsibility into the conflict over the treasure.
Mercutio
Mercutio is Romeo’s witty, bold, and unpredictable friend. He adds humor and energy to the play, but his death changes everything. When Tybalt kills him, Romeo’s grief and anger lead to revenge, banishment, and the tragic spiral that follows.
Smaug
Smaug is the dragon who guards the treasure under the Lonely Mountain. His greed and destruction create the central problem of The Hobbit. Even after he dies, the treasure he guarded continues to cause conflict among dwarves, elves, and men.
Tybalt
Tybalt is Juliet’s hot-tempered cousin and one of the most violent characters in Romeo and Juliet. His hatred of the Montagues fuels the feud. By killing Mercutio, he triggers Romeo’s revenge and pushes the play toward tragedy.
Beorn
Beorn is a powerful skin-changer who can take bear-shape. He helps the travelers earlier in The Hobbit and later returns during the Battle of Five Armies. His arrival helps turn the battle against the Goblins and Wargs.
Sophia Auld
Sophia Auld is one of Douglass’s enslavers. At first, she teaches Douglass the alphabet and seems kind, but slavery changes her. Her transformation shows one of Douglass’s major arguments: slavery damages both the enslaved and the enslaver.
Elvenking
The Elvenking is the ruler of the Wood-elves. He imprisons the dwarves earlier in the story, but later shows wisdom, restraint, and generosity. Near the end, he honors Bilbo as “elf-friend,” recognizing Bilbo’s courage and goodness.
Edward Covey
Edward Covey is a brutal man known for “breaking” enslaved people. Douglass is sent to him during one of the darkest parts of the Narrative. Covey’s cruelty leads to one of the most important turning points, when Douglass physically resists him and begins to reclaim his sense of manhood and power.
Since Douglass is historically real and not fictional, I would frame his matchups carefully as literary figure / narrator / historical voice, not “character” in the same way as Bilbo or Romeo.
Online Directions
Cross-Genre Character Championship
Ms. Kalinowski will display two characters from different texts.
Students will compare the characters using evidence from the stories.
For each matchup, students should decide who is stronger as a literary figure.
Students may argue based on courage, growth, wisdom, impact, theme, or memorable choices.
Students will vote in the chat or poll.
The winner moves forward in the bracket.
For the final matchup, students will write a three-sentence championship pitch.
Student Debate Sentence Starters
I choose ___ because…
___ shows more courage because…
___ changes more than ___ because…
___ has a bigger impact on the story because…
___ reveals the theme of ___ better than ___ does.
Even though ___ is important, ___ should win because…
Final Pitch Prompt
In three sentences, explain why your finalist deserves to be the Cross-Genre Character Champion. Use one piece of evidence and one theme word.
Example:
Bilbo should win because he changes from a comfort-loving hobbit into someone brave enough to face danger, dragons, and conflict. His choices show courage, mercy, and loyalty, especially when he tries to prevent war by giving up the Arkenstone. Bilbo proves that ordinary people can become heroic without losing who they are.
This would be a very strong last-day activity because it lets them argue across genres instead of just remembering plot. It turns the whole year into one ridiculous literary cage match with standards hiding under the floorboards.
Vote for the character who best shows:
Courage
Do they face danger, fear, pressure, or injustice?
Growth
Do they change, learn, or reveal complexity?
Impact
Do their choices affect the plot or other characters?
Theme
Do they help teach an important message?
Evidence
Can you prove your choice with something from the text?
Final winner rule:
The champion is not just the most popular character. The champion is the character students can defend with the strongest evidence.
